“They tried to bury us, but they didn’t know we were seeds.”
India & Liberalisation | India and Space Research – Past
& Present
How A False Case against ISRO Nambi Narayanan had brought down the Chief
Minister of Kerala
“No power on earth can stop an idea whose time has come.”
How Russia ‘halted’ its promised tech transfer to India under
US Pressure
Nambi Narayanan & V. Narayanan | Quirky Similarities
An Inspirational Analysis
This day, 32 years ago, from my personal diary entry
1st January 1994
#memoriesfromdiaries
This is my second year of keeping a personal diary. Yes,
officially, I was into my second year of journalling, in the year 1994.
And this particular year’s diary entries
assume added significance for me, since it was from 1994 that I started
documenting all the news-worthy articles in the day’s newspapers onto my
personal diary.
[On an aside, back then, when I was so sincerely jotting down
this diary entry, never ever in my farthest dreams would I have imagined that,
a day would come when I will be posting memorable vignettes from my past diary
entries on this ‘futuristic something’ called a blog or a weblog!] 😊
Coming back –
This particular day’s newspapers in English (The Hindu)
had four newsworthy articles, as follows -
1. PM Rao rejects FM Manmohan Singh’s Resignation
2. TN Bill on Reservation Passed
3. Russia to Supply Four Rocket Boosters
4. In Rajasthan, the Sekhawat Government proves majority
So why-on-earth did the Union Finance Minister Dr.
Manmohan Singh submit his resignation? 🤔
And why-o-why did the Prime Minister reject his
resignation? 🤔
Well, on 31 December 1993, Dr. Manmohan Singh, the
Union Finance Minister, offered his resignation to Prime Minister P.V.
Narasimha Rao, owning moral responsibility following a highly critical report
by a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC).
The backdrop to his resignation was the 1992 Securities Scam
involving ‘Big Bull’ Harshad Mehta. A Joint Parliamentary Committee was formed
to investigate the scam. In its final report, submitted in late December 1993,
the committee indicted the Ministry of Finance and the Reserve Bank of India
(RBI) for serious failures in oversight.
Known for his high personal integrity, Dr. Singh felt
that as the head of the Finance portfolio, he had to take moral responsibility
for the lapses.
However, Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao did
not accept the resignation, stating that, the country was in the middle of
crucial economic reforms and that Dr. Singh’s leadership was indispensable for
India’s financial stability.
So what are the crucial economic reforms heralded by Dr.
Manmohan Singh, known as the ‘Father of Economic Reforms’ in India?
When Dr. Manmohan Singh took office in June 1991,
India was on the verge of facing its worst economic crisis ever, signalling an
impending bankruptcy ahead.
Can you imagine a dire situation way back in May 1991 -
just before Dr. Singh took office - when the government – as a dire financial
emergency – had to airlift 20 tonnes of gold from India’s reserves to the Union
Bank of Switzerland to raise $200 million.
And
yet again in July 1991, under the new Rao-Singh government, another 47 tonnes
of gold had to be ‘urgently’ shipped to the Bank of England to secure a $400
million loan.
In fact, this very act of mortgaging India’s gold
reserves was a psychological shock to the Indian public, as gold is culturally
seen as the ultimate safety net.
This is when Dr. Manmohan Singh’s role assumes a lot of
significance.
On 24 July 1991, Dr. Singh presented a landmark budget in
Parliament, that slashed subsidies, and opened industries to private
competition, and invited foreign investment.
His reforms, famously known as LPG
(Liberalisation, Privatisation, and Globalisation), fundamentally shifted India
from a state-led model to a market-driven economy.
Dr. Singh had famously concluded his 1991 budget speech
by quoting Victor Hugo’s inspirational lines -
“No power on earth can stop an idea whose time has come.”
This quote literally gives us the goosebumps, ain’t it? 😊
Some of the proactive measures he initiated are
as follows –
First and foremost, he broke the concept of
“Licence Raj” that dictated what a company could produce and how much.
Secondly, he initiated the concept of privatisation, thereby
reducing state dominance. As a result, the number of industries reserved
exclusively for the government was slashed from 17 to three: Railways, Atomic
Energy, and Defence.
Thirdly, he pioneered globalisation in India.
Before 1991, India’s economy was largely closed to foreign trade and
investment.
Finally, he heralded reforms in the banking
sector, thereby giving banks more freedom to set their own interest rates
rather than following strict RBI mandates. This paved the way for the entry of
modern private banks (like HDFC and ICICI), which modernised the Indian banking
landscape.
Coming back to the second important newsworthy article
featured in this particular day’s newspapers!
It is on Russia’s supply of four rocket boosters to India.
Well, well, well…. this is indeed a real
gripping narrative that has all the elements of a good spy novel or a techno
thriller to it.
Probably the literary being or the film director in you can
try coming up with a spy novel on this episode! 😊
You see, way back in the early 1990s, the Indian space
programme was inching ahead boldly, towards a major breakthrough that would
change global satellite launch dynamics forever.
Towards this end, in 1991, India’s ISRO signed a landmark
$120 million deal with the Russian space agency, Glavkosmos, with the avowed
aim of acquiring two cryogenic engines and, crucially, the technology transfer
to build them in India.
However, Big Brother United States, was not at all happy you
see!
Led by the Clinton administration and
pressured by then-Senator Joe Biden, the United States vehemently opposed the
deal. They claimed that it violated the Missile Technology Control Regime
(MTCR), raising fears that, cryogenic technology could power Intercontinental
Ballistic Missiles (ICBMs).
Added, by 1993, Russia was facing a staring at a huge
economic crisis. The U.S. offered Russia a $24 billion aid package - but with a
massive string attached: Cancel the promised tech transfer to India.
Hence, under intense pressure, President Boris
Yeltsin of Russia had to bow to US pressure-tactics. In December 1993, a
strategic compromise was struck with India. Russia would supply seven engines
(up from the original two), but without giving away any technology transfer, or
training.
This way, Russia could keep the cash and the U.S. aid;
India gets the engines, but is denied the ‘brain’ to build them.
But wait! Therein lies the story!
Or
so the world thought… 😊
While diplomats from Russia and India were busy signing
papers in public, ISRO was running a secret operation in the shadows.
Russia was secretly helping India with ‘technology transfer’ in
a subtle and discreet way without Big Brother’s knowledge. 😊
Since Air India required public manifests that
U.S. intelligence could track, ISRO turned to a Russian carrier: Ural Airlines.
The Ural flight containing ‘technology transfer and the
blueprints’ were officially logged in as transporting Indian aircraft parts to
Russia for ‘wind-tunnel testing.’ However, in reality, the underbellies of
these planes were packed with heavy cryogenic stages and loads of technical
manuals.
At the Khimki facility in Russia, Indian engineers
worked 24/7 to photocopy thousands of pages of blueprints, whisking them to the
airport before the legal window slammed shut.
Project head Nambi Narayanan later revealed that he and other
senior scientists didn’t just coordinate from desks - they were on those
flights, literally sitting in cargo holds or cockpits to ensure the crates
weren’t intercepted by ‘American spies’ reportedly swarming Russian space
centres.
Just as ISRO began integrating the smuggled
technology, the momentum was halted in October 1994, by the infamous ISRO Spy
Case that broke in!
Nambi Narayanan and his deputy were arrested on charges of
selling cryogenic secrets to Maldivian spies. The media went into a frenzy
damaging the credibility of Nambi and his deputy.
Luckily, in the year 1996, the CBI cleared the scientists,
concluding the case was a complete fabrication (by the US). Many, including
Narayanan, believe the scandal was a CIA-led operation designed to dismantle
India’s cryogenic programme just as it was taking flight.
This threat of denial of technology or technology
transfer forced India to start the Cryogenic Upper Stage Project (CUSP) from
scratch.
It took two decades of gruelling research, and finally in the
year 2014, India successfully launched a 100% indigenous cryogenic engine.
“They could delay us, but they couldn't stop us.”
Today, we’ve come a long way from scratch to self-reliance.
And it is so heartwarming to see how
India has prided herself on the space front.
Thought of reproducing an article in The
Times of India, Chennai Edition, dt 1st January 2025, where ISRO Chairman S
Somanath gives a press briefing on India’s space achievements in 2024 and
informs them about upcoming launches.
True to his word, India has been a forerunner in launches in
2025.
Reproducing an article from The Times of India
dated 25th December 2025, which shows how we have evolved over the decades.
.jpg) |
| From 1st January 2025 (a year ago) |
It is indeed a full-circle moment for the Indian space
programme, contrasting the struggles of the 1990s with a record-breaking
commercial success in 2025.
While in the early 1990s India had to
‘smuggle’ cryogenic technology to survive U.S. sanctions in 1993, this article
reports on ISRO’s heaviest-ever launch - ironically carrying a U.S.
communications satellite!!!
 |
| 25 December 2025, Times of India |
What an amazing geopolitical shift it has been!
Indeed a a complete reversal of the 1993 era
- where the U.S. actively blocked India’s progress, in sharp contrast to today
– which saw India acting as the service provider for a U.S. company!
The article also foregrounds the fact that, India has moved
beyond the original Russian technology, by utilising new indigenous upgrades to
increase payload capability by over 150kg.
The mission marks ISRO’s 434th satellite deployment over a
45-year history.
On a very interesting note - quite a range of
coincidences exist between V Narayanan, the current ISRO Chairman and Nambi
Narayanan, the past ISRO Chairman.
Both
share the same names.
Both
are from Nagerkoil, Tamil Nadu.
Both
are cryogenetic engine technology pioneers - One of the most complex challenges
in aerospace engineering.
Both
were first-rank holders in their respective degrees.
Both
went through a lot of early hardships in their early life and education.
Both
held the prestigious position of Director of the Liquid Propulsion Systems
Centre (LPSC), the heart of ISRO’s engine development.
Both
have been recognised by the Indian government and the scientific community for
their contributions to space exploration.
When Nambi Narayanan was ISRO Chairman, in the early 1990s,
the young V. Narayanan was one of the
young engineers sent to Russia during that era to train on the Russian engines.
They later used that experience to lead the team that built the 100% indigenous
version.
A real poetic conclusion indeed!
Well, for more on this saga, there are two must-read
books from Nambi Narayanan and the second one from Rajasekharan J Nair, that
reveal a lot of truths behind this bitter episode.
I’ve read the first one! The second one – I’m reading
now!
The first one by Nambi Narayanan is titled, Ready to
Fire: How India and I Survived the ISRO Spy Case published in the year 2016.
The book provides a firsthand account of the 1994 ISRO espionage scandal,
written by the man at the centre of the storm - scientist S. Nambi Narayanan.
[On an aside, the movie, Rocketry: The Nambi Effect,
written, produced, and directed by R. Madhavan, who also played the lead role
of Nambi Narayanan, was also based on this book.]
The book details on Nambi’s personal battle for justice –
on how as a senior scientist leading India’s cryogenic engine project, he was
falsely accused of selling rocket secrets to Pakistan through Maldivian
conduits.
Moreover, the book also serves as a memoir of India’s
space journey, chronicling the evolution of ISRO from its humble beginnings
under Vikram Sarabhai and Satish Dhawan.
Beyond Narayanan’s personal ordeal, the book
argues that the spy case was part of a larger international conspiracy intended
to sabotage India’s space programme. He argues that –
The entire case was foisted on him targeting the
development of India’s Cryogenic technology, which would have made India a
major commercial player in the global satellite launch market. He suggests that
certain officials in the IB and Kerala Police may have been “pawns” for foreign
agencies (such as the CIA) to stall India’s “inevitable march to space.”
And I quote from the book –
This was the same tactics the US had employed to stop the USSR
from transferring the cryogenic engine technology to India in the early 1990s.
The US argued that cryogenic engines fell
under technology for missiles. This was far from the truth.
No country, including the US, has a missile with a cryogenic
engine. But already under the strain of the impending fall of the Soviet Union,
the Russian facilities buckled under American pressure and changed the contract
to just sell seven cryogenic engines, and not transfer the technology.
That this delayed India’s cryogenic programme by at least
fifteen years is another tale.
On 20 October 1994, Thaniniram, a
Malayalam eveninger, broke a story of a woman spy being arrested in Trivandrum.
It spoke about a woman called Mariam Rasheeda, 38, a Maldivian spy on a mission
to Trivandrum to get secret drawings of Indian rocket engines.
CPM mouthpiece Desabhimani followed up the story
the next morning. Two days after the Maldivian woman’s arrest, Kerala Kaumudi,
another Malayalam daily, dropped a bombshell: Inspector General of Police Raman
Srivastava, an officer considered a favourite of Chief Minister K Karunakaran,
has links with the spy ring.
On 13 January 1995, hearing a public
interest litigation (PIL) by an NGO called Niyamavedi, a division bench of the
Kerala High Court headed by Justice Sreedharan made some adverse comments on
the CBI investigation, which did not find any evidence to link Srivastava with the
case.
This led to the IPS officer’s suspension on the same day.
The CBI moved the Supreme Court bench of Justice Sujatha Manohar and got the
remarks expunged.
But by then, K Karunakaran was forced to step down
as the Chief Minister after the opposition and a faction of the Congress
accused him of shielding Srivastava and aiding the spy ring.
I felt sad for the senior IPS officer. A man
respected in service and outside has been dragged into this cesspool. How? Why?
I was to learn how bitter politics between two factions in the Congress in
Kerala—one led by then Chief Minister K Karunakaran, and the other by A K Antony
and his Man Friday Oommen Chandy—made this officer a scapegoat. It was no
secret that Srivastava was one of Karunakaran’s favourite police officers.
It so happened that when the ISRO spy case
broke out, a faction within the Congress party that was in power in Kerala,
too, found it an opportunity to bring down K Karunakaran from the Chief
Minister’s chair. This they succeeded when A K Antony, then Oommen Chandy’s
leader, replaced Karunakaran in March 1995,
says
Nambi Narayanan.
To sum it all up, at the end of it all, the subtle moral
we glean from this episode is that –
The clouds may conspire to cloak the sun, and the wind
may claim the day is won; but while the storm spends its fury in the street,
the stars remain patient, and the truth, complete.
How
true!
And lastly, for the icing on the cake – and coincidentally at
that – today’s The Hindu dt. 1st January 2026, Editorial Page carries a
very insightful article on the Advancements in India’s Space Programme.
It’s written by former ISRO Chairman S. Somanath. The article
looks upon space as a “global commons” under Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam. (the
world is one family)
Somanath
says -
India’s space journey has evolved
beyond a string of spectacular missions. In June 2025, when Group Captain
Shubhanshu Shukla displayed the Tricolour aboard the International Space
Station (ISS) and spoke to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, it was a moment of
pride for every Indian.
That same spirit has been echoed earlier,
on August 23, 2023, when Chandrayaan-3 made India the first nation to land near
the lunar south pole.
India’s lunar programme has been truly
path breaking: Chandrayaan-1 (2008) confirmed the presence of water molecules;
Chandrayaan-2 (2019) mapped the moon with high precision and prepared the
ground for Chandrayaan-3 (2023), which achieved the world’s first soft landing
near the south pole.
When the Vikram lander and Pragyan rover
explored the lunar surface for a full moon day, this led children to draw
depictions of lunar landscapes in notebooks, it left researchers feeling
vindicated, and inspired citizens who saw India’s story in space as also their
own future.
Over 400 foreign satellites have been
launched aboard Indian rockets. In 2014, India became the first Asian nation
and only the fourth in the world to reach Mars orbit — and on its maiden
attempt, with the Mars Orbiter Mission (Mangalyaan).
The Aditya-L1 mission (2023), built
through multi-institutional collaboration, is providing unprecedented insights
into the sun’s corona and its impact on space weather. XPoSat (2024) is
studying black holes, while SpaDeX (2024) has demonstrated in-orbit docking for
future space stations and lunar missions.
On a personal note I felt that, the article looks at the
brighter side of things, while carefully avoiding the seamier side.
The author has made quite a point on how space
exploration fuels Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM)
education, advanced research, and workforce development.
However, as past Chairman of the ISRO, and from the rich
insights he must have gained, he could also have taken time to emphasise on how the annual
exodus of thousands of India’s brightest aerospace engineers who still continue
to migrate to NASA, SpaceX, or Blue Origin, could be ‘stemmed’ and on
strategies by which India can take efforts to retain its top-tier talent. That
would have made the article a wholesome treat.
That lacuna apart, this is indeed a timely
article on how India’s space journey is more than rockets and satellites. It is
about a nation discovering new ways to see itself!
PS: You may want to read this blogpost on
Cultivating the Lovely Art of Writing / Journalling / Diary Writing HERE on our
blog.