Saturday, 29 March 2025

"Kundu Mani was used as a unit of measurement, because of their consistent weight" - Tree Walk @ MCC Today

The Trees are Alive! | Nature Trails Walk in MCC

29th March 2025 | A Report

When an eminent ethnolinguist and a Botanist Came Together for a Tree Walk

Listening to tree and trail connoisseurs is indeed an experience. It ‘modifies your sensibility’. Today proved to be such a day, when you had your sensibilities enriched for the better, in the company of legends. 

The Nature Trails Walk in MCC, started sharp at 6.45 am near the College Bell Tower.

Dr. Nirmal Selvamony, pioneer of Ecocriticism in India, Dr. Narasimhan, eminent botanist, (who also has a few species of plants named after him), Dr. Reji, Staff Advisor of Scrub Society, and Dr. Rufus accompanied the students.

The first stopover was on Principal’s Drive, where Dr. Narasimhan introduced us to the uniqueness of the trees lined up on either side of the Principal’s Drive – of the Bignoniaceae family, also known as the trumpet vine family, known for their beautiful, trumpet-shaped flowers.

They are very shallow-rooted but grow very tall. This is one of the unique characteristic features of rain-forest trees, particularly in South American rainforests. The rainforest trees are so dense, and the trees act as a dense canopy. 

Moreover, these rainforest trees are known for their impressive height, reaching up to 200 feet or even more. These trees have large, flared roots (buttress roots) that extend above the ground, providing stability in the often-soft soil and helping to absorb nutrients from the surface.  The buttress roots provide side-support to the tall trees. (When Dr. Nirmal gently intervened to say – the word buttress is an architectural term that they’ve borrowed!), he averred.

Dr. Edward Barnes was the architect of this campus. He found the birds and bats dispersing seeds, and he allowed such plants to grow! That’s why you find a beautiful scrub jungle in Campus. Barnes recorded every plant that came up. You look up the old College magazines, and you can find how meticulously he has recorded all the plant varieties. Wherever he went, he used to bring back a load of seeds. Those are the plants that have taken shape now, and adorn the campus. So the plants here are not bought from nurseries, said Dr. Narasimhan.

The Flowering Plants of Madras City and its Immediate Neighbourhood is a book written by Pallassana Vaithi Pattar Mayuranathan, Superintendent, Government Press, 1929, where there are empty papers kept between its pages and bound. And in these empty pages, his wife Alice Barnes has written beautiful notes about the College. Both Dr Barnes and his wife Alice Barnes were working together on this. It’s now in the College Library. You just have to ask the College Librarian, he added.

If the Magazines are not available, the British Museum has documented all of this. You can access it there as well. At that point of time, they micro-filmed everything. Now it would have been digitized. Our College Magazines are great historical material, suggested Dr. Nirmal.

“Every avenue has a story. You have to dig it up and tell your friends”, said Dr. Narasimhan.

Dr. Reji added that, yet another interesting point is that, Dr. Barnes was not a Botanist at all. He was a Chemist, who was very passionate about plants.

The Nerum Oleander which is colloquially called the Arali flower is indeed a very poisonous plant. All parts of the plant - including the flowers, leaves, stems, and roots, contain toxic cardiac glycosides, which are poisonous. Interestingly, the fruit of the arali plant is edible, and I’ve also tasted it, said Dr. Narasimhan.

The Arali plant doesn’t need much water too. That’s why it’s planted in the medians of highways, he added.

We also had a look at the Aana Kundu Mani (Kunnikuru in Malayalam) Abrus precatorius also called the Crab eye plant - a slender, climbing herb with peculiar bright red seeds. It is usually found creeping over shrubs, plant and hedges. It is also considered a toxic herbal plant because of the presence of abrin toxin in the plant seeds, said Dr. Narasimhan.

Dr. Nirmal added to say that, Kundu Mani was used as a unit of measurement, because of their consistent weight! In fact they were prized and cherished for their weight, that remained a constant even under varying moisture conditions, due to the water-impermeable seed coat. Hence it was called the jeweller’s weight. I’ve seen it in my father’s office. It was a very small balance.

The seeds were used to weigh gold and other precious materials, with a single seed representing a unit called “ratti”, and eight such seeds were supposed to measure one sovereign, said Dr. Narasimhan.

That’s why the expression, ‘oru kundumani thangam kooda veetla illa’ meaning – There’s not even one ratti of gold in the house, alluding to the poverty of the house.

Pooja added to say that, in Kerala, these bright red manjadi seeds are commonly used to play the traditional board game Pallanguzhi. Dr. Nirmal joined in to say that in Tamil Nadu tamarind seeds were used to play the same game.

Our next stopover was the rose wood, which is called the bastard rose wood, since it is not the original rose wood. In the process he also busted a lot of myths associated with certain trees, plants and fruits.

Dr. Nirmal then added to recommend a book by Ms. Maneka Gandhi titled, Brahma’s Hair: The Mythology of Indian Plants in which she writes about the wonderful world of mythology that has grown around thirty Indian plants and trees.

Then we moved to the beautiful red sanders tree. Usually, the red sanders sports a ‘once-forked’ branch on them, said Dr. Narasimhan.

Dr. Reji added an interesting observation saying that, many architects have made use of the structure of the red sanders for their architecture.

It’s called Biomimicry in architecture, also known as biomimetic design - a design approach that draws inspiration from nature to create innovative and sustainable buildings by studying and emulating natural systems and processes.

I have a friend called Mr. Shankar from Thrissur gives lectures on Biomimicry, added Dr. Narasimhan.

At this point, Dr. Nirmal added to say that, literature students would have been introduced to the area of ecosemiotics, in which biomimicry is a subfield.

Near the Red Sanders, Dr. Nirmal recollected the exact spot as the place where the poetry group called Vanam used to meet regularly. Na Muthu Kumar (late) one of the founding members of the group, was also part of this Vanam, he added.

Vanam published two anthologies – Vaanam Piranthathu (the Sky is Born) which is prescribed in Tamil Departments in many institutions, and available in the College Library, and the next book is titled, Vanam Malarnthathu.

Dr. Nirmal then recited a poem from one of the books, (written by him) on Mullaipuravu – and the ideal location for a family is Mullai, he averred.

Dr. Narasimhan gladly intervened to say that, he had written one such poem in Tamil which was translated into English by Dr. Nirmal. It’s titled, Mannithuvidu Magane. (Forgive me, my son). Someone who listened to the poem found it so profound, that they translated it into Hindi, he said.

“The beautiful river sand in which I once danced, you don’t have them anymore…” goes the poem.

MCC is typical mullai landscape, plains and places with low elevations, while Kurinji is places with high elevation, places where animals graze, said Dr. Narasimhan.

A scrub jungle, said Dr. Nirmal.

So usually places ending with ‘Paadi’ are Mullai region.

Vyasarpadi, Vaniyambadi, Katpadi – where cattle graze, he said.

Kurichi, Alwarkurichi is Mountainous, while words ending in Paakam come under Neithal.

Marutham is a riverine place. Maruthancode in KK District is an example, said Dr. Narasimhan.

To be continued…

The Tree Walk ended with a stroll to the College Cafeteria. 

PS: You may want to read on yet another past Tree Walk we had in Campus 13 years ago, on 28th January 2012, HERE, on our blog.

Friday, 28 March 2025

"If I have made you poignant, if I have made you distressed, I owe you no apology. My purpose is to wake you up. Would you like to continue to sleep in the waking posture? That is left to you"

T. N. Seshan’s A Heart Full of Burden

An MCC-ian’s Burden for his Motherland | A Memoir

Reading books written by Officers in the Civil Services, can offer reams of valuable on-the-ground, real-world perspectives to pressing issues of civil society, to the layperson in general, and for those interested in public service, governance, and the workings of the Indian administrative system, in particular.

Honest Officers in the Civil Services are a rare breed. They offer such valuable real-world perspectives in dealing with complex administrative challenges, policy implementation, and the realities of governance at the grassroots level.

One reason why, reading their books can offer profound reflections on these challenges and provide valuable lessons on integrity, accountability, and public service.

This book by Shri T. N. Seshan, IAS, is one such book, that provides real-world perspectives that go beyond theoretical knowledge. It not only offers a unique insider’s view of the Indian bureaucracy - its strengths, weaknesses, and the challenges – but also presents the plethora of ethical and moral dilemmas that many of the honest Officers in the Civil Servies have had to face in their careers, in their tryst with truth and honesty.

So yes! continuing our dream run on yet another Chief Election Commissioner Shri T. N. Seshan, who’s written such a profound book on his motherland – A Heart Full of Burden.

Well, as this illustrious alumnus of MCC says, on the purpose behind writing this book –

If I have made you poignant, if I have made you distressed, I owe you no apology. My purpose is to wake you up. Would you like to continue to sleep in the waking posture? That is left to you.

On an aside, the book is no longer available for buying in the public domain. Although there were three reprints in 1995, due to public demand, the book has had no reprints from then on!

Added reason why me thought of presenting a few perceptive insights from the book for the future pillars of our Nation – especially our budding Civil Services Aspirants – who might find a noble purpose behind their call – through the words of T. N. Seshan.

So yes... what makes this book unique?

The entire book of 155 pages feels like he is in a candid, heart-to-heart conversation with his reader. Such is his spontaneity, his command over his language, and his appeal to the conscientious soul!

Feels so heart-warming to even know that we’ve had IAS Officers of his rank and file who have transformed society for the better in their own unique ways. And how!!!

Presenting a few lovely excerpts from his Introduction to A Heart Full of Burden –

If a statement of truth gets a man dubbed a cynic, call me so. I am not a cynic. I am not an escapist either. Nor do I deny the astronomical leaps taken by the country, particularly in comparison with those who gained freedom at the same time in history as India.

We were at a starvation corner in 1947. Today we are not only self-sufficient in food but are among its exporters. We had a wretched skeleton of an industrial base, mainly composed of agro-products, and a small number of textile mills, coalfields and ore mines.

Today we are the tenth largest industrialised nation of the world, manufacturing or at least assembling almost everything from a safety pin to a supersonic aircraft.

From a nation which produced only office clerks, we have now become a nation whose prowess as the third largest bank of techno-economic power is unquestioned. All this cannot be denied.

But the dignity of the individual, the inner strength of human character, and the courage to accept and do only that which a man in his conscience believes to be correct, that self-respecting mettle which is nurtured only by true education and persistent exercise, and ‘maketh a nation great and strong’, in the true sense is as deplorable today in the age of supersonic aircraft as it was in the age of bullock-cart.

The India of my dreams is not an India of high-tech economic advancement. It is a vision which perhaps died with the freedom fighters – “where the mind is without fear and the head is held high” – it is that haven of freedom into which we still have to lead our ancient nation.

The dignity of the individual which is at the heart of the cosmic concept of fraternity and national pride is inalienable to my dream of a strong and free India. Justice, Liberty, Equality and Fraternity – the hallmarks of a living democracy – are elusive ideals unless the individual gets his due.

A democracy is one in which the rule of law prevails. People are ruled by consent enshrined in the laws made by their chosen representatives, and have a right to dissent and challenge that which is illegal and underhand.

Coercion of any kind, mental, economic, political or intellectual, is a form of violence and should not find no place in any democracy. 

From a statistical point of view, we have the largest number of laws, covering and uncovering almost every aspect of human life. But the inside out of democracy today is that law is obeyed more in circumvention and defiance than in effect.

Consider the case of two women who were raped in the Arabian deserts in 1991. The guilty were brought to book and executed in a record time of six months; and compare it with the thousands of rapes which were committed in 1991 in India, and even if, out of some of these cases, charges are framed, they are still under a review. Justice in such circumstances can only be called a joke.

A democracy is one in which the true choice of the people gets reflected in the public representatives. We have yet to make a beginning in that direction. Elections in India continue to make a beginning in that direction.

Elections in India continue to yield to the manipulative tactics of the privileged few whether privileged by sheer dint of, being in power at the sacred time of the poll or being privileged to be able to commandeer enough financial resources to influence and purchase the people’s choice.

A third category of the privileged professionals who are swarming the holy precincts of our legislatures are the musclemen who first worked for those who began to depend on them to browbeat the voters and then preferred to displace their erstwhile masters.

Absence of purity in our election process is at the root of corruption in India. I dream of an India in which the voter shall be able to assert his true choice and will be free and aware enough to identity the appropriate man for the helm of affairs.

Public awareness is the key to a vibrant and living democracy — awareness of what ails the nation, what are our ills and what remedies are best under the prevailing environment, awareness of what are the rights and obligations of the citizens and what a faithful exercise of these rights will contribute towards the general good and well-being of all.

And this awareness which has always been the proud possession of the vibrant Indian psyche has played a second fiddle all through our recent post-Independence period. Our system of education is still limited in its approach.

“Education” said Hazlitt, “is that which remains in us after we have forgotten what we learnt in books.”

Education in India is still bookish and merely career-oriented. It does not train fully grown, aware and self-assured young men and women to swim confidently in the tumultuous ocean of the competitive and conflict-ridden society. Women who constitute half the mass of people are still by and large deprived.

The India of my dreams, though technologically keeping pace with the world and economically sound and self-sustaining, will be only an India of clay and mud if the foundations are not built on human character and honesty sustained by education which nurtures the human personality in its true sense.

- T. N. Seshan

In short, T. N. Seshan’s A Heart Full of Burden (a collection of his addresses) is more of a personal reflection that delves into the heart of the Indian democratic electoral process and politics.

And as the title itself suggests, “A Heart Full of Burden,” hints at Seshan’s personal sense of “agony at the nation’s present condition” at that point of time, presenting on a platter, his views on the Indian democratic electoral process and the state of Indian politics.  

Seshan not only expresses his noble aspirations and concerns about public life, but also uses his inimitable “no holds barred” and “no-punches-pulled” style to critique politicians, bureaucrats and goonda elements who infest and infect the land, reflecting his deep sense of respect for democratic values and the Indian constitution.  

PS: You may want to read our past post on Shri T. N. Seshan’s visit to his alma mater MCC on 6th March 2013, where he was honoured with the Distinguished Alumni Award, HERE.

Shri T. N. Seshan at MCC, 15 years ago - 6th March 2013

Thursday, 27 March 2025

Founders’ Day Quiz - Reg.

27th March 2025

Dear All,

Sub: Founders’ Day Quiz on Wednesday, 2nd April 2025 – Reg.

The Founders’ Day Quiz aims to celebrate and acknowledge the vision, dedication, and contributions of the founders of our College.

The questions will focus on the rich heritage and legacy of Madras Christian College.

The Quiz will be facilitated by Dr. Kalapati Joshua, former Head, Department of Philosophy, MCC, and co-author of the book titled, Life and Legacy of Madras Christian College with staff coordination from Dr. Marilyn Gracey Augustine, Curator of the College Archives, and conducted by Quiz Master Ben.

https://forms.gle/bSiKaTNVt5ztczpr7

First Place: Rs. 3,000/-

Second Place: Rs. 2000/-

Third Place: Rs. 1,000/-

Students interested in participating in the Founders’ Day Quiz, may register in the Google Form provided, on or before 31st March 2025

Dr. P. Wilson

Principal 

"Ms. Muraleedharan had spotlighted the pockets of revanchism, colourism, and misogyny that festered unnoticed in Society" 💜

Entrenched Colourism | Deep-seated Colour Biases in Society

#newspaperinlearning

#today’snews 💜

Today’s Newspapers in English foregrounded a social malaise that’s been wreaking havoc on civil society for ages - the deep-seated colour biases in society, that result in value judgments based on one’s skin colour.

Well, I’ve highlighted some of the terms related to colourism in green, to foster better academic engagement with this social malady of our times - in our prospective debates, discussions and dialogues.

‘I am a woman and I am dark. It’s time I own both of these’

Times of India, dt 27th March 2025

Kerala chief secretary refuses to let a comment about her complexion slide, instead chooses to confront underlying biases and value judgments

It was a bold and daring call against colourism, by none other than the Chief Secretary of a State, when Sarada Muraleedharan fired back Wednesday at a remark about her skin colour, as it compared her tenure being “as black as her husband’s was white”. In a Facebook post, which she initially deleted but later reposted, she spoke out against deep-seated colour and gender biases in society.

The comment likened her administration to the colour black, while her predecessor and husband V Venu’s was called “white”.

Without naming the person behind the remark, Muraleedharan hinted at sexism in the criticism but refused to let the insult define her.

“I think it’s high time for me not to feel defensive about either the fact that I am a woman or that I am dark,” she said, according to news agency ANI. “It’s time that I own both of these and that I come out strongly. Maybe it will help those people who are going through similar feelings of insecurity and inadequacy to feel that we are worth it and we don’t need external validation.”

Taking to Facebook, she addressed the cultural fixation with fairness and shared a childhood memory of struggling with it. “As a four-year-old, I asked my mother whether she could put me back in her womb and bring me out again, all white and pretty,” she wrote.

“Behind the humour, there is an entire value connotation that black is not good, that there is something wrong with it,” she told ANI. “What is wrong about black? Isn’t it more a perception than a reality? It is important to claim blackness as something worthwhile and beautiful.”

Her response sparked a wave of support across political lines. Opposition leader VD Satheesan of Congress called her words “alarming” proof that even a high-ranking official isn’t immune to discrimination.

Kerala Chief Secretary sparks a social debate on ‘entrenched colourism’

The Hindu, dt 27th March 2025

Kerala Chief Secretary Sarada Muraleedharan has sparked a social debate on “entrenched colourism” in society.

In a powerful and poignant Facebook post on Wednesday, Ms. Muraleedharan highlighted the jarring inequity of skin tone bias against women in workplaces, hiring practices, professional evaluations, and the social arena.

Ms. Muraleedhran noted she was a victim of the entrenched prejudice against women of dark complexion and implied that being at the apex of the administration was no insulation against the bigotry. “I heard an interesting comment yesterday on my stewardship as the Chief Secretary – that it is as black as my husband’s (former Chief Secretary V. Venu) was white. Hmmm. I need to own my blackness,” she wrote.

Shades of misogyny

Ms. Muraleedharan also discerned shades of misogyny in the questionable attempt to draw a judgemental comparison between the respective public service careers of the IAS couple. “It was about being labelled black with that quiet subtext of being a woman as if that was something to be desperately ashamed of,” she noted.

At a stroke, Ms. Muraleedharan tapped into a wellspring of support in her public crusade against entrenched colourism. For one, the Leader of the Opposition V.D. Satheesan said Ms. Muraleedharan had torn the veil over established colourism in Kerala society. “I am the child of a dark-skinned mother,” he noted.

Historian, social critic, and Professor at the Centre for Development Studies J. Devika said the provenance of discrimination against dark-skinned persons was a historical burden bequeathed to society by the country’s colonial past. “Not skin tone, but Ms. Muraleedharan’s life, character, and career defined her,” she said.

Actor Cuckoo Parameswaran stated, “Perceived blackness resides in the prejudiced eye of the beholder.” She said early hiring practices based on skin tone in the entertainment industry were on the wane.

Kerala State Youth Commission chairperson Chintha Jerome said Ms. Muraleedharan had spotlighted the pockets of revanchism, colourism, and misogyny that festered unnoticed in Kerala society. “The younger demographic is increasingly progressive,” she said.

Now coming back to our discussion on colourism, I would like to quote from two seminal books on the subject - 

Firstly, I’d like to quote from Rae Johnson’s article on the subject, titled, “Queering/Querying the Body: Sensation and Curiosity in Disrupting Body Norms”, from her book titled, Oppression and the Body: Roots, Resistance and Resolutions. Rae is a social worker, somatic movement therapist, and scholar/activist working at the intersections of embodiment and social justice.

Body Norms, Body Shame, and Social Power

It has been argued that the more marginalized and subordinated a social position we occupy, the more we are identified as bodies and the more pressure we experience to modify those bodies to reduce our deviance from the norm.

In other words, one way to enact oppression against members of a particular social group is to characterize them as bodily objects rather than intelligent and sentient subjects, and to simultaneously depict those bodies as uncivilized, crude, ugly, or distasteful.

As the multibillion-dollar cosmetics, plastic surgery, and weight-loss industries readily attest, women are prime subjects of such pressures to modify their bodies; however, members of other socially disempowered and vulnerable groups are hardly exempt.

The elderly are routinely encouraged to retain the appearance and functioning of their youth, as evidenced by an anti-aging products and services market expected to exceed $300 billion, while the effect of widespread and entrenched colorism supports a global market for skin-lightening products that is projected to reach $23 billion by 2017.

Of course, the cost of having a body considered substandard, deviant, or otherwise problematic cannot be measured in dollars alone. Body shame is a significant source of emotional and psychological distress, with consequences ranging from depression and diminished quality of life to social isolation and suicide.

For example, body objectification and dissatisfaction are increasingly prevalent among youth; a cross-sectional survey of Brazilian school children found a body dissatisfaction rate as high as 82 percent, with young girls at particular risk.

Given the fluidity, complexity, and contingency of bodily appearance and conduct in signifying social power and shaping identity, how do members of socially subordinated groups reclaim some authority over their body image in the process of liberation and empowerment?

As subjects whose very identities are (at least in part) socially constructed, how do we interrogate and illuminate the choices, compromises, and creative impulses to shape our body in particular ways?

How do we understand questions of agency and intent in the ongoing transformations of our body selves?

As we expand the range of our own bodily expressions to include representations that may have been prohibited or censured by the social worlds in which we live, how do we avoid the danger of advancing those counter-cultural expressions such that they become the new norms that others are expected to emulate? In exploring these questions, two analytic/methodological tools may be useful: queer theory and somatics, she avers.

Secondly, yet another important book on the subject by Carla Rice, titled, BECOMING WOMEN The Embodied Self in Image Culture, throws light on ‘Seeing Difference Differently’.

Carla Rice is Professor of Feminist Studies and Social Practice at the University of Guelph. She specialises in social justice, feminist studies, intersectionality, decolonizing, arts-based research, disability arts, fat studies, embodiment, and digital storytelling.

The book provides a highly nuanced approach to the colonisation of the woman’s body by beauty industries.

I quote -

In a culture where beauty is currency, women’s bodies are often per ceived as measures of value and worth. The search for visibility and self-acceptance can be daunting, especially for those on the margins of conventional Western notions of beauty. Becoming Women offers a thoughtful examination of the search for identity in an image-oriented world.

That search is told through the experiences of a group of women who came of age in the wake of second- and third-wave feminism, and focuses especially on voices from marginalized and misrepresented groups.

Carla Rice pairs images from popular culture with personal narratives to expose the “culture of contradiction” where exhortations for body acceptance have been matched by even more restrictive feminine image ideals and norms.

Drawing on insights gained from her advisory role with the Dove Campaign for Real Beauty, Rice exposes the beauty industry’s colonization of women’s bodies, and examines why “the beauty myth” persists.

Seeing Difference Differently

Women marginalized in research and media reporting joined the dialogue because they wanted to re-vision conventional accounts and enrich understanding about the implications of difference.

Leigh hoped to fill a gap in popular magazines and studies that focused solely on white or American women: “Women’s magazines don’t cover diverse viewpoints. We need research relevant to the racial make-up of Canadians.”

Treated as marginal in feminist writing on beauty that addresses mainly white women’s issues, women of colour enrolled as a way of advocating for greater inclusion and representation –

“I was reading this feminist book and the person who had read it before me had written in the margins, ‘This is only a white woman’s point of view.’ So I’d like to give my perspective” (Rose). Even when books or articles stress experiences of Black or Asian women, authors still tend to take an ethnocentric approach by looking at issues primarily from a single group’s vantage point.

For multiracial women who see themselves as having many identities (being Black, Asian, and female, for example), the ethnocentric perspective is inadequate to capture the nuances of their embodiment: “I found books focusing on Caucasian or Black women only. I didn’t find books that understood women with multiracial back grounds. They weren’t relevant to me” (Ada).

Racialized women in this research did not see their concerns as identical to white women’s. (The term “racialized” refers the social process of viewing non-dominant racial groups according to pre-existing racial categories and stereotypes, which reproduces the categories as significant identities and sources of inequalities).

Many sought to move the conversation beyond size to include issues of hair and hue: “It wasn’t so much size, it was also colour. In my family, I’m lighter so kids at school would tease me. I realized then that people judged based on colour” (Sharon).

As a result of living in a country where citizens are imagined to be white and where other groups are divided into ethnic and racial silos, many confronted barriers to belonging that negatively affected their embodied being, she notes!

PS: You may want to listen to a Talk I had given on the subject of Trauma and Colourism, at Govt. Arts and Science College, Ollur, Kerala on 22nd November 2018. The topic of the Talk was, “Trauma, Epistemic Violence and the Archive”, HERE.

Wednesday, 26 March 2025

"Similarities between Jews and Kashmiris have persisted. For example, graves are arranged east to west; coffins have a pointed top; the period of mourning is forty days; smoked fish is a common meal; 9 per cent of Kashmiri still consists of Hebrew words" ❤️

Reflections | On Mr. Lyngdoh, IAS, former Chief Election Commissioner

& his Book on the J & K Elections 2002

Did Jesus travel to Mesopotamia, Iran, Sind, Varanasi, Puri and Nepal?

Did Jesus stay in a Buddhist Monastery for Six Years?

Are There So Many Similarities between Kashmiris and Jews?

Today we had an official delegation from Synod College, Shillong, Meghalaya, with us on a three-day visit to interact with the Officials of the College.

The delegation was headed by Dr. Gayreen Lyngdoh, Principal, along with Dr. Wancydora Kharmawphlang, IQAC Coordinator and Prof. Adrian K Langstieh, Assistant Professor of Commerce, an Alumnus of MCC [Economics, 2012-15].

The word Lyngdoh took me back by two decades, when India had Mr. J. M. Lyngdoh as the Chief Election Commissioner of the Nation.

Pardon me for deviating from the main agenda from here on! Just that my mind impulsively took be back to two decades ago - 

Almost every other day, back then, Mr. Lyngdoh IAS used to come on primetime news!

Call him yet another vibrant T. N. Seshan on the ground! 

So in all curiosity I asked Principal Mrs. Lyngdoh if the past CEC Mr. Lyngdoh IAS, has any connection with the college, since I’ve been all ears on him ever since he became the nation’s CEC.

Principal Dr. Lyngdoh then explained the origin of the name ‘Lyngdoh’. She clarified that - 

the surname ‘Lyngdoh’ is derived from the Khasi words lyng meaning to be born and doh meaning to be a leader or to guide. 

This suggests a connection to leadership or a significant social role within the community, possibly indicating that the original bearers of the surname were leaders or influential figures in their villages. Hence the word connotes to mean, they belong to the priestly class in the Khasi kingdom.

The Khasis have a rich cultural heritage, and hence their surnames usually reflect the social structure and roles within their matrilineal society, where lineage and inheritance are traced through the mother.

Well, from here on, we shall go ahead and discuss our former Chief Election Commissioner J. M. Lyngdoh –

Well, Lyngdoh became double-famous after his retirement, when he published a book with Penguin, titled, Chronicles of an Impossible Election.

The book is highly informative in its ambit, and the language is equally engaging for a light read albeit a wee bit ‘controversial’ in its scope as well! 😉

Firstly, the language that’s so lucid and so cool.

Secondly, his ‘second chapter’ titled, ‘Of History’ that gives an astounding purview of the land in all its grandeur. This historical sweep takes us down ages past - to some very surprising events as well.

It seems Jesus - between his thirteenth and twenty seventh years, had travelled from Mesopotamia to Iran, Sind, Varanasi, Orissa and Nepal. He was six years in a Buddhist monastery and imbibed so much of Buddhism as to be considered an Arhat. And he was thought to have transmitted much of Buddhism to Christianity, for example, celibate monks and nuns and the concepts of the trinity…

The story is endlessly gripping and wonder-amazing!

I personally feel that, (on an aside), the only thing that lacks in the book is a strong historical foundation to back his research credentials. Else, the book would have become a great sensational hit by now! Still, very interesting finds.

Thirdly, his take on the Role of the Election Commission and its Constitutional Status.

Finally, a gripping, first-hand account of how he had conducted the elections in a free and fair manner, that would serve as a manual for all his successors to follow!

Just giving us all excerpts –

The Kashmir problem was intrinsically one of an uncommonly cerebral people, extremely sensitive, very conscious of their identity as an ancient, distinct race inhabiting the paradisal vale of Kashmir, enduringly proud of their past but consumed with anger at what they perceived as successive subjections to a variety of contemptuous rulers (most books on Kashmir splurged colourful but coloured quotations about the Kashmiri character), as well as a persistent indignation over hundreds of years at their own defensive prevarication.

But what was the Kashmiri's historical perspective?

There is compelling evidence that Kashmiris are descended from the Kassite or Kash tribe - hence Kasheer or Kashmir - or the Biblical Kush, after Noah’s grandson, Kush. (The important tribes before them in the Valley had been the Nagas, Pishachis, Gandharas and Turganas.)

And similarities between Jews and Kashmiris have persisted. For example, graves are arranged east to west; coffins have a pointed top; the period of mourning is forty days; smoked fish is a common meal; koshered meat has always been de rigueur; birth, marriage and death rites are identical; 9 per cent of Kashmiri still consists of Hebrew words.

Apocryphal, Sanskrit, Buddhist and Islamic sources together showed that between his thirteenth and twenty-seventh years, Jesus, who was an Essene - Essenes, a sect among the Jews as distinct from the Pharisees and Sadducees, were noted for their poverty, honesty, justice and equality-travelled from Mesopotamia to Iran, Sind, Uttar Pradesh (Varanasi), Orissa (Puri) and Nepal (Kapilavastu).

He was six years in a Buddhist monastery and imbibed so much of Buddhism as to be considered an Arhat. And he was thought to have transmitted much of Buddhism to Christianity, for example, celibate monks and nuns and the concepts of the trinity and of offering the other cheek to one who had struck you on one cheek. Returned to his homeland and ever defiant of orthodoxy, he was crucified. But since he soon attained samadhi and appeared dead to the uninitiated he was allowed to be removed from the cross.

The Essenes treated his wounds with spices and salves and laid him in a grotto. It was there that he recovered. Obliged to distance himself from his enemies, he with his mother again took to the east-Iran, Central Asia, Punjab (Taxila) and Kashmir (Srinagar), where he was eventually buried.

Jesus' grave, which also had a wooden sepulchre, was known as the shrine of Yusu Asaph of Rosabal. Mary's grave was in the neighbouring Pakistani hill resort of Murree (derived from Mary).

Much older, Moses' grave on the hill of Nabu in Bethpor was known as the shrine of the 'Prophet of the Book'. And lying at the feet of the hill of Nabu, the Valley, scripturally - most of the place names in the Bible matching with those in that part of Kashmir- topographically and ecologically, out of all places on earth, best exemplified he promised land of the Bible. Evidently the Kashmiris were one of the ten lost tribes of Israel.

As part of the Jewish diaspora from Mesopotamia to Kashmir, the Kashmiris were not rigid about religion and changed with the wind. They became Hindus Emperor Ashoka, prior to his conversion, founded the city of Srinagar-and then turned to Buddhism.

The third century Buddhist Conference in Kashmir, in the reign of Kanishka, saw the birth of Mahayana Buddhism. Kashmir, the only part of the subcontinent with four distinct seasons and a natural apprehension of seasonal symbols, had always been strongly Saivite, appreciating the trinity of Shiva the destroyer, Durga the creator and Parvati the preserver.

It was Kashmiri Saivism which gave to esoteric Hinayana Buddhism—in which each individual had to work out his own deliverance from suffering - a comfortable, anthropomorphic divine order composed of Shiva the Supreme Being and of the gods and goddesses of the cult who could be manipulated for private purposes. 

The orientation of Buddhism towards society promoted the Bodhisattva, the person who, instead of striving for his own salvation, stayed on in the world to show to others the way of attaining the blessings of the Dhamma.

Just provided excerpts for y’all.

You may want to buy the book online or borrow the hard copy of the book from this blogger by simply dropping me an email.

With the simple blessed assurance that you would review the book on your blog, once you are done reading it! 😊 

Featured post

Four Urgent Interventions to Reimagine Indian Academia ❤️

Why Having Great Faculty on the Rolls is the Real Asset of World-Class Universities Hindustan Times 18 November 2026 #newspaperinlearning I...